The weather in Jeromeville was always beautiful in October. Jeromeville got very hot in the summer, but by October the weather had cooled to a happy medium, still warm enough to be outside without the intense heat. My routine this October was a little different from that of previous years, but I was settling into what would be my routine for this year. Drive 19 miles down Highway 100 to Nueces for student teaching. Come home. Eat lunch. Go to class in the afternoon. I was still volunteering as a youth group leader at Jeromeville Covenant Church on Wednesdays, I was still going to Jeromeville Christian Fellowship’s large group meetings on Fridays, and I was in a Bible study with JCF on Tuesdays, led by my friends Courtney Kohl and Colin Bowman.
The baseball postseason was happening, but I was not following it. The Bay City Titans were tied for the last playoff spot and lost the tiebreaker game. Two players on other teams that year, Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa, had broken the previous record for home runs in a season; McGwire’s 70 had become the new record, which would only stand for three years. While that had attracted many fans back to the sport that had lost fans in 1994 after a labor strike had ended the season early, many baseball purists would later look negatively on this era. Many of the home run hitters of that time were using performance-enhancing drugs, or suspected of doing so, since baseball had more lenient rules about some substances that were banned in other sports.
I was also going swing dancing every Sunday at the University Bar & Grill. Swing dancing was the big fad of 1998. Many of my church friends had gotten into swing dancing over the last year, and while I resisted for a long time, having no interest in dancing, I finally gave it a try a few months ago and really enjoyed it. My roommate Jed Wallace was really into swing dancing, and he went to the U-Bar on Sundays too, but many of my friends who were regulars there when I first started going had been there less often since school started again.
One Sunday morning that month, I sat in church trying to pay attention. The worship team played a few songs at the beginning of the service. Then the pastor got up and spoke something which I am sure was very nice, about some meaningful passage from the Bible. But no matter how hard I tried, I could not pay attention, because I knew what I had to do today once the service was done, and that was all I could think about.
Of course, the world would not end if I did not go through with it. This requirement for today was entirely self-imposed. But I felt like I was going crazy, and whatever the outcome, good or bad, I knew that I would feel better once it was done.
It started a week ago. Actually, it started months ago, but all of these thoughts intensified a week ago. There was a welcome back potluck after church that week, to coincide with the start of fall classes. Someone from the church had constructed a temporary dance floor out of plywood on the lawn between the church entrance and the parking lot. After the potluck and dance party, the dance floor would be disassembled and used to build a new stage platform at the end of the church sanctuary building, where the worship team plays and the pastor preaches, about eight inches off the ground. I dressed for church that day the same way I normally dressed for swing dancing: a white t-shirt, clip-on suspenders, black slacks, and a gray flat cap, the one I bought a while back when I went shopping with Bethany Bradshaw. Bethany was not here this morning; she went to a different church.
Several non-dancers at church commented on my attire. I said thank you and explained that it was for swing dancing.
After the service, after everyone had had time to eat, I heard swing music start playing. I did not know the name of this song, but I had heard it before at the U-Bar. I could not see who was controlling the music. Maybe someone had just put on a Best of Swing Dancing CD of some sort. The technology existed now to make custom CDs that were playable in ordinary CD players, so maybe someone made a custom mix CD of swing music. I danced a few times with friends whom I knew were dancers.
About six or seven songs in, I saw Sasha Travis standing on the side of the dance floor, looking like she wanted to dance. She wore a dark blue dress that came down to her knees. Her hair was long and straight and brown, the same way she always wore it. I walked up to her and asked, “Would you like to dance?”
“Sure!” she replied, smiling. I led her to the dance floor, and we began dancing to “Zoot Suit Riot” by the Cherry Poppin’ Daddies. I was starting to get annoyed with this song; it was overplayed, it was always the first thing that people on the outside of the swing dancing revival movement associated with modern swing dancing, and Jed went on this whole rant recently about how much he hated this song and how it was not real swing music. But I was willing to put all of that aside if it meant getting to dance with Sasha.
Step, step, rock-step. I had been doing this for a few months now, and the basic step had almost become automatic to me. I started doing some turns, lifting my arm and turning Sasha to the time of the music. “I really like that hat,” Sasha said, smiling.
“Thanks,” I replied. “It’s the same one I’ve been wearing for at least a month now.”
“I know, but I like it.”
A little bit later, I led Sasha into an inside turn, where she moved across the front of my body. As she did, she playfully grabbed my hat and put it on her own head. “That looks good on you,” I said, hoping that she would not notice that I was starting to get sweaty, and that the hat had absorbed the sweat of the last month and a half at the U-Bar.
“Thanks!” Sasha said, smiling. I continued dancing with her for the rest of the song. At the end of the song, I dipped her into my arm. She tried to reach up to hold the hat on, but I knocked it off, grabbed it before it hit the ground, and put it back on my own head.
“Thank you for the dance,” I said.
“Thank you!” Sasha answered. The two of us walked back to the side of the dance floor and talked with some of our mutual friends until people asked them to dance.
Ever since the moment Sasha stole my hat, a week ago now, I could not get her off of my mind. It felt like I was thinking about her all the time, in the car on the way to my student teaching assignment, while I was helping those students learn math, while I sat in class.
I took three deep breaths in my seat after church ended, and I walked outside. I saw Sasha walk outside that door just a few seconds ago; hopefully she was not in a hurry to get home. She stood talking to Courtney and Erica, her roommates. I walked up, ready to ask Sasha if she had a minute to talk, but Courtney saw me first and said, “Hey, Greg! How are you?”
“Pretty good,” I said.
“How was your weekend?”
“Nothing special. Just catching up with studying and homework. Probably going swing dancing again tonight at the U-Bar.”
“That’s fun!” she said. “I won’t be there tonight.”
After Courtney turned to talk to someone else, I knew I had to force myself to say what I needed to say, or else I would chicken out again. I walked up to Sasha and said, “Sasha? Can I tell you something?”
Sasha turned toward me, clearly not expecting this. “Okay,” she said. I stepped about ten feet away, out of earshot of anyone, and motioned for her to follow me.
“I’ve really enjoyed getting to know you these last several months,” I explained. “I like dancing with you, and I enjoy hanging out. I was wondering… I really like you, and I was wondering if you were interested at all in, you know, being more than just friends.”
Sasha gave me a strange look. I was not sure what to make of it, but whatever would be the typical reaction of someone getting this news and being interested in return, this was not it. “Greg, I’m sorry,” she said. “You’re a really nice guy, I’ve enjoyed hanging out too, but I just don’t see you that way.”
I nodded slowly for a few seconds. “That’s ok,” I replied. “You don’t need to apologize. I just feel like I’m at the point where I need to say something. I needed to know.”
“I understand,” she said. After a few seconds of silence, she added, “Don’t feel bad.”
“I won’t,” I replied. “Will you be at the U-Bar tonight for dancing?” I asked.
“I won’t be there tonight. But have fun!”
“I will,” I said, trying to sound enthusiastic.
When Jed and Brody moved into this house, Brody suggested that we do a communal meal once a week. The rest of us approved of this idea. Tonight it was Sean’s turn to make dinner, and he made some dish with chicken and rice. I did not talk much at dinner. I did not feel like talking. Brody asked me at one point how my weekend went, and I just said fine without giving any details. Brody mentioned that he would not be having dinner with us next week, because it was his birthday and his family was taking us to dinner. Jed told us all about how he had just bought the album Americana Deluxe by a swing band called Big Bad Voodoo Daddy on CD. After dinner, as we were cleaning up, Jed put his CD on; I recognized some songs from swing dancing at the U-Bar.
Later that night, I was in the large bedroom I shared with Jed, sitting at my desk reading for one of my classes. Jed walked in and asked, “Hey, is everything okay? You seemed kind of distant at dinner.”
“I just have stuff on my mind,” I explained.
“I don’t want to pry, but I have a question for you.”
“What is it?”
“After church, I saw you talking to Sasha,” he said. My heart sank. How much did Jed know? Was he going to make a big deal and make fun of me, put me down for my choice of women? Was he going to tell me it was inappropriate for me to feel that way, since she was only eighteen years old and I was twenty-two? He continued, “I was talking to her a few minutes later, and she was acting really weird, not her usual self. And you’re not your usual self tonight. What were you two talking about? Is this all connected?”
I sat in my chair, looking up at Jed, then looking off into the distance, trying to figure out how much to say. I did not want anyone knowing about any of this. I did not know that Jed would be talking to Sasha immediately after I did. But he was not exactly being intrusive; he did not talk to her after church with the intention of finding out what I had told her. He was simply being observant.
“This is just between us… promise?” I said.
“Yes.”
“I told her I liked her, and she didn’t like me back.”
Jed nodded. “I wondered if it was something like that,” he said.
“Hmm,” I replied, still not looking Jed in the eye. I wondered if my actions had been so obvious that everyone at church knew by now. But then again, maybe not; had I been in his position, observing all that he had about me and Sasha today, the same thought probably would have crossed my mind.
“Sorry about that,” Jed said. “Is it going to be weird seeing her at church and being friends with her roommates and everything?”
“I don’t know,” I answered. I really did not.
“Have you been out with her a lot?”
“Not like one-on-one. Just hanging out in the same circles, and dancing, and stuff like that.”
“She probably wasn’t expecting you to say that, then.”
“I guess. I’m just so bad at this.”
“Everyone goes through this. Don’t let it get you down.”
“I’m trying not to. But it’s hard.”
Two days later, I was driving east on Coventry Boulevard, still thinking about Sasha. I had managed to go all day Monday and Tuesday without seeing Sasha or any of her roommates on campus, and no one else had mentioned Sasha to me since I talked to Jed Sunday night. But my destination tonight was Bible study, and Courtney, one of the leaders, was one of Sasha’s roommates. If Sasha had been acting strangely after our conversation on Sunday, strangely enough to give Jed an outline of what was happening, then I assumed that her roommates were likely to know at least part of the story as well. If she told them what she told Jed, though, I did not know if she had identified me as the guy who she rejected.
Things like this were why it had always been so hard for me to communicate my feelings toward women. Back in the spring of 1990, as I was finishing middle school, my friend Paul Dickinson asked me if I liked a girl named Rachelle Benedetti, because he noticed I was often looking at her or trying to talk to her or something like that. I admitted to Paul that I liked Rachelle, within a week it seemed like the whole school knew, and I was mortified. I did not want everyone I knew to be in my business like this.
For an hour and a half, for most of Bible study, I thought that maybe I had gotten away with it. Everything felt normal. The only time I talked about things other than the passage of Scripture that we studied was when I got there and Colin asked me how student teaching was going. But I was wrong. After the study, I was usually in the habit of not rushing home, catching up with my friends first for a while. Courtney came up to me a few minutes after we finished, and asked, “How are you doing? I heard about what happened Sunday.”
“Yeah,” I said, not sure where to take this conversation. Courtney seemed sympathetic, at least. “I’m okay, I guess.”
“There’s someone out there for you,” Courtney said. “Just keep praying about it.”
“I guess,” I said, trying to act appreciative of Courtney’s concern instead of rolling my eyes at the dumb cliché.
“They always say love finds you when you stop looking for it.”
Great, I thought. An even worse cliché. I heard that all the time, but how would love find me if I stop looking for it? I was not really actively looking, I was just living my life, and no one had found me yet. Of course love would find someone like Courtney when she was not looking for it; she was a pretty blonde girl, bubbly and friendly. I was not so lucky. I just said, “If you say so.”
“Everyone goes through this. It’s just part of life. You might need time, but someday you’ll wake up and feel like it’s time to get over it,” she said. “Like when Brody and I broke up, I needed a few days to just sit with my feelings, but now everything is okay, and we’re still friends.”
More mildly angry thoughts bubbled in my mind. I had no idea that Courtney and Brody broke up. I was always the last to know anything. These people were in the closest thing I had to an inner circle of friends. Brody even lived at my house. And yet I had no idea what was going on in their lives. Apparently I was not in either of their inner circles, or anyone’s for that matter. “That’s good,” I finally said, dejectedly. “I’m not upset with her. She didn’t do anything wrong.”
“Who didn’t do anything wrong?” Colin asked, walking over to see what we were talking about.
“It’s nothing,” Courtney replied. “Just something Greg said to someone that was taken the wrong way.”
“Yeah,” I said. Courtney seemed to be deflecting the conversation away from the topic of Sasha now that Colin was within earshot, and for this I was thankful. I did not want too many people to know about this. But just in case, I added, “I don’t really want to keep talking about it, if that’s okay.”
“That’s fine.”
I was still thinking about this when I drove home later that night. I was twenty-two and had never come close to having a girlfriend. Things were starting to feel hopeless. I had no idea what I was doing, and it seemed to come so much more easily to everyone else than it did for me. No girls liked me, and nothing I could do would change that.
Part of the problem was that I did not know how to communicate my feelings to a girl. When I was interested in someone, I always felt like I had to keep it a closely guarded secret, so she had no idea. Why was I like this? Probably because I grew up constantly being teased for everything, so I was just used to doing whatever I could not to give metaphorical ammunition to bullies, even though I really had not experienced much traditional bullying as a university student. Also, my mother and her extended family were always in everyone’s business, and I did not want my romantic interests to become public knowledge that everyone started talking about.
But, I realized, on those few occasions where people did know about my romantic interests, none of what I feared happened. Sure, back in middle school, Paul told a lot of people that I liked Rachelle, but they did not make fun of me for it. He was just trying to help. At the end of that year, when we took the honor roll trip to the amusement park at Mount Lorenzo Beach, he let me sit next to Rachelle when we rode the Giant Wave. Jed and Courtney were not making fun of me about Sasha either; they just did not want to see me get hurt.
That was pretty much it. The topic of Sasha rejecting me never really came up again among any of my friends. It stayed on my mind for a long time, though. The next time I had to change my password, a few months later, my new password combined the numbers on Sasha’s license plate with the name of a villain character from a TV show. I used that password for over a decade, long after she was no longer a daily thought. And almost two years after she rejected me, when I was ready to buy my first car with my own money, I decided to make a decision on a car that day instead of sleeping on it, because the next day was Sasha’s birthday, and I did not want my car to have the same birthday as a girl who rejected me.
When Sasha first met the guy she ended up marrying, who was also one of my church friends at the time, it felt a little awkward being around them. But Courtney was right about one thing: after a while, things would start to feel okay again.
Readers: Do/did you share with your friends who you are/were interested in romantically? Tell me why or why not in the comments.
If you like what you read, don’t forget to like this post and follow this blog. Also follow Don’t Let The Days Go By on Facebook and Instagram.


